The Dream Mountain Home you’ve been waiting for!! A looping driveway winds through towering pines to an elevated homesite that makes a stunning first impression. Designed for mountain living, this custom retreat features an oversized 3-car garage with 10′ x 10′ door, built-in dog wash, and adjacent workshop/ski storage. The single-level floor plan offers privacy and function, with the primary suite at one end and four secondary bedrooms plus a game room at the other. Above the garage, an oversized bunk room captures sweeping valley views. The chef’s kitchen includes double pocketing windows framing westerly views, an oversized island, and a hidden prep area with second sink and dishwasher. Three fireplaces offer cozy gathering spaces throughout. Located in Whitetail Club, minutes from the Fish & Swim Club, this is a lifestyle-driven retreat designed for all seasons.
Property Details
Price:
$4,890,000
MLS #:
543738
Status:
Active
Beds:
5
Baths:
7
Type:
Single Family
Subdivision:
Whitetail PUD 2
Listed Date:
Nov 24, 2025
Lot Size:
90,169 sqft / 2.07 acres (approx)
Year Built:
2024
See this Listing
Schools
Interior
Additional Features
Primary Bedroom on Main, Sprinkler System, Central Air
Full Baths
6
Half Baths
1
Exterior
Paved Street
1
Financial
HOA Fee
$2,280
Tax Year
2024
Taxes
$9,440
Map
Community
- Address5608 Appaloosa Trail McCall ID
- SubdivisionWhitetail PUD 2
- CityMcCall
- Zip Code83638
Subdivisions in McCall
- 0 Not Applic.
- Alpine Village
- Ashbrook
- Ashton Ridge
- Aspen Ridge
- Aspen Village
- Aspens Condos
- Big Valley Estates
- Bighorn
- Black Hawk
- Blackhawk
- Blackhawk Lake
- Blackhawk on the River
- Blackhawk Ranch
- Blue Jay
- Broken Ridge
- Brookdale Meadow
- Brundage
- Buckcamp
- Carefree Sub
- Cedar Knoll Acres
- Coho Estates
- Comfort Woods
- Coy Estates Subdivision
- Crystal Blue Waters Condominiums
- Davis Beach
- Deadhorse Creek Cottages
- Elds Country
- Elkhorn Sub
- Evergreen Terrace
- Fairway Ridge
- Fircrest Condominiums
- Forest Trails
- Fox Ridge
- Geelan Addition
- Greystone on Payette
- Greystone Village
- Half Moon Cove
- Hearthstone
- Hoff and Brown
- Jacobs Manor
- Jug Mountain Ranch
- Jug Mountain Ranch McCall
- Jughandle Est.
- Jughandle Estates
- Jughandle Highlands
- King’s Pines Estates IV
- Kings Pines Estates
- Knob Hill Estates
- Lake Fork Estates
- Lake Fork Landing
- Lakefork Acreages
- Lardo Subdivision
- Lick Creek Meadows McCall
- Longview Acres
- Lucks Point
- McCall Acreage
- McCall Landing
- McCalls First
- Meadow Lake Estates
- Merganser
- Mountain View Estates
- Non Applicable
- Payette Lake Club
- Payette Lakes Cottage Sites
- Payette River
- Payette River H
- Pearson Corners
- Pinewinds Condos
- Point of Rocks
- Ramos Sub
- RedHawk Ridge
- Rio Vista
- Rio Vista #5
- River Ranch McCall
- River Ranch Valley County
- Rivers Bend Condos McCall
- Rivers Crossing
- Rustic Village
- Shadow Ridge
- Shaw Valley Estates
- Shiner Creek Condominiums
- Silverpine Village
- Ski Ranch Subdivision
- Spring Meadow C
- Spring Mountain Meadows
- Spring Mountain Ranch
- Spring Mtn Ran.
- Sylvan Beach
- Syringa
- T & M Acres
- Thompson-Wooley
- Timberlost II
- Timberlost III
- Timberlost IV
- Timberlost V
- Timberlost VI
- Valley View Estates
- Village Condominiums
- Village Condos
- Village II Condos
- West place
- White Clouds
- Whitebark Estates
- Whitetail
- Whitetail Sub
- Wildwood Condos
- Wilhelm Creek
- Woodlands #1
Market Summary
Current real estate data for Single Family in McCall as of Apr 22, 2026
68
Single Family Listed
130
Avg DOM
$2,090,444
Avg List Price
Property Summary
- Located in the Whitetail PUD 2 subdivision, 5608 Appaloosa Trail McCall ID is a Single Family for sale in McCall, ID, 83638. It is listed for $4,890,000 and features 5 beds, 7 baths, and has approximately 0 square feet of living space, and was originally constructed in 2024. The average listing price for Single Family in McCall is $2,090,444. To schedule a showing of MLS#543738 at 5608 Appaloosa Trail in McCall, ID, contact your Ralston Group Properties, LLC agent at 2087035666.
Similar Listings Nearby

5608 Appaloosa Trail
McCall, ID

